2

There was a site proposed in Area 51 called Hardware Recommendations. It is now in public beta and I think it would be helpful to migrate and redirect users with hardware questions to this site instead of just closing their questions.

My request is to add this site in the options when closing a question via

This question belongs on another site in the Stack Exchange network

  • +1: I agree. We get tons of these types of posts and it would nice to be able to get them in a queue to more easily manage than endless comment debates. – JakeGould Dec 24 '15 at 4:30
  • Which one would you replace? (Considering we don't add beta sites on that list in the first place) – random Dec 24 '15 at 4:43
  • I don't want to be critical, but... The site is currently only 71% answered. Do you really think they're better off sent away rather than redirected toward a problem-based question here? – Shog9 Dec 24 '15 at 4:43
7

Public beta's too early for migration anyway, and considering the two recommendations sites are unique in their scope and previous experience as a moderator on software recommendations I'm not sure this is the greatest idea.

If someone asks a question that's clearly and explicitly off topic, its probably a clear sign that the question needs some adult supervision.

If a question's clearly on topic there there and excellent - meeting their quality standards in every way, and you flag it for moderation, chances are no one will yell at you. We'll be a little confused why it was asked here.

Quite often though, the process we've always had in place - suggesting people drop into chat, talking to them about what they're trying to do, and more recently, passing them on to hardware recommendations if needed, seems to work well.

In short, its a terrible idea for now while HR's still in the beta stages.

If we're discussing re-jigging our migration targets, it would probably in the future, and we'd need to decide one of the current ones is no longer needed.

  • Thanks for the reply. After reading the answer and the comments, I can see how it wouldn't be suitable at this point in time. Perhaps it may be an option in the future. – MC10 Dec 24 '15 at 17:25
  • Typically Beta sites are left to their own vinces, if they make it, only then would we migrate a hardware/software recomendatio question. Besides if it's closed here they can always ask it in the proper place...themselves – Ramhound Dec 24 '15 at 20:47

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .