14

I was browsing for a solution to download files from a link into Google Drive and came across this answer, which is a community wiki, and has at the bottom of it the text

EDIT: Please note that this answer dates from 2014, which is a long time ago in computers. There is no point in downvoting if the extension no longer works.

I had previously thought that the purpose of downvoting was to indicate that an answer does not work. However, this is my first time I consciously remember considering downvoting a community wiki, so I figured the rules might be different, so I should ask here.

Do community wikis have different conditions as to when one should downvote?

19

No, there is no difference.

If the answer is wrong, doesn't work or whatever else in terms of not being helpful, it warrants a downvote.

Being set as community wiki, or even being old, is not a guard against a downvote.

  • 10
    Furthermore, the notice itself should be removed from the answer, it is an inappropriate meta-commentary, that does not belong outside of the metacommunity (in my opinion). Worth pointing out the answer could be protected so nobody could upvote or downvote it. – Ramhound Mar 28 at 14:43
  • @Ramhound "Protected questions have the additional restriction that new users are not permitted to answer the question. Unlike locked questions, they can still be edited, commented on, and voted on. You can even vote to close them. – DavidPostill Mar 28 at 15:19
  • 1
    @DavidPostill - I could have sworn I have seen answers themselves protected, in such a way, where they could not be voted on. However, I am aware of the difference between a closed question and a protected question. I was just pointing out there was an alternative solution to prevents downvotes, to an answer that isn't accurate but still helpful. – Ramhound Mar 28 at 15:30
  • 5
    @Ramhound You're thinking of Locked posts – Canadian Luke REINSTATE MONICA Mar 28 at 15:48

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .