4

As we already know that Super User is a for computer enthusiasts and power users but we have different sites for Linux questions such as:

  1. Unix and Linux - for users of Linux, FreeBSD and other Unix-like operating systems
  2. Information Security - for Information security professionals (mostly which are related to Linux)
  3. Ask Ubuntu - for Ubuntu users (also Linux based OS)
  4. Server fault - for system and network administrators (also includes Linux ).

So the question is -
Why the questions related to Linux are not migrated to these sites?
Why they are not considered off-topic?

7

Sites on the Stack Exchange network do tend to overlap in scope. It is not the case that a question asked on a more "generalist" site is automatically off-topic on that site once another site comes along that is more specific.

The more specific targeted sites, like AskUbuntu, Unix&Linux, etc. are designed to give users a community that shares a lot in common. This increases the likelihood of better quality, more direct answers. But that doesn't mean that those questions can't be asked on Super User anymore.

Generally, my guidelines would be:

  1. If you know of a StackExchange community that specifically caters to the nature of the problem you're having, then ask your question there.

  2. If you don't know of a site that is very "zeroed-in" on the issue you're having, but you can find a generalist site where it's on-topic, like Super User or Stack Overflow, then you can ask it there. If you get an answer that's useful, great! If not, after waiting a week or so for answers, you can request migration to a more specific site.

  3. If another user asks a question on a "generalist" site that's clearly more likely to receive better answers on a "specialized" site, we should first attempt to answer it here on the generalist site without reference to the specialized site. If no one knows the answer after a while (a week or two), you can ask the OP if they would like to have it migrated to improve the likelihood of a better answer. Then the SU mods can work with another site's mods, vet the question (to verify that it's on-topic and of good quality), and migrate it if everything looks good.

4

Because they arn't. We have a wider scope. In one word ewoks.

Computers are our scope, and so those things are not off topic for us

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .