I agree that [tag:selection] as a tag is too broad. **However**, when viewing the questions it's used with, a few separate topics emerge:

- **Text selection** [meta-tag:status-completed]: usually paired with an OS, browser, or program tag. Some examples:
  - https://superuser.com/q/173200/107240
  - https://superuser.com/q/553757/107240
  - https://superuser.com/q/224865/107240
  - https://superuser.com/q/85772/107240
  - https://superuser.com/q/482266/107240

- **Image selection**: [meta-tag:status-completed] usually specific to image editing/manipulation programs, like GIMP or Photoshop:
  - https://superuser.com/q/577247/107240
  - https://superuser.com/q/925394/107240
  - https://superuser.com/q/463585/107240
  - https://superuser.com/q/413364/107240

- **File selection**: OS and program level:
  - https://superuser.com/q/175807/107240
  - https://superuser.com/q/506597/107240
  - https://superuser.com/q/915653/107240
  - https://superuser.com/q/768412/107240

There are some other uses, but these are the main three, and in my opinion they are topics worthwhile of having tags. So rather than completely burning, it may be better to split it into [tag:text-selection], [tag:image-selection] or [tag:file-selection]. (For other uses of [tag:selection], complete removal is more warranted). 

The main three would be solid topic areas when paired with the appropriate program or OS tag. What do you think?