How is [my question](http://superuser.com/questions/402991/software-to-track-things-ive-read-watched-and-played) worse than, for example, [this one](http://superuser.com/questions/127503/any-software-to-keep-track-of-my-reading-progress)?

I believe I have provided a fairly comprehensive list of requirements, so that a best answer would be possible. Of the 10 requirements I've noted, only 2 could be considered subjective (History of privacy-consciousness and inoffensive interface).