I will take the other side of this debate.  I think that closed questions should be reserved for SPAM, people trying to jerk things around, and totally inapproprite questions for any other locations on the web. 

It still wouldnt change the fact that the Question is not what, or How you would ask at a Local BBQ around your friends,  It is more akin to something we might see TEXTED from a cell phone while your driving down the road :-)   So I can understand why there is little appretiation for it.

Because a question can be edited, you could do a better question, still.

You still have what I concider to be very adequite comments and answers, With the way the question was asked.   If you needed an "answer" from what I can see you got it.  If you needed more input on the question, and various opinions and experiences on standby , I would like to see that HERE. 

I myself do not see anything wrong with layers of different peoples experiences and learnings, and leanings on a question.