Skip to main content
added 244 characters in body
Source Link
fixer1234
  • 27.8k
  • 2
  • 38
  • 96

This question uses the tag as an example, but it applies to any acronym tag that doesn't have a universal and common usage (like, say, pdf).

is a new tag. I drafted a wiki and excerpt for it based on the usage so far (which refers to Android Debug Bridge). As DavidPostill points out in a comment, adb ADB already has multiple computer-related uses (alsoas DavidPostill points out in a comment, also Advanced Debugger, and user2943160 mentions Apple Desktop Bus), so an acronym tag is just asking for misuse.

Based on adb already referring to multiple things, the logical approach is to have spelled-out tags for each use and an adb tag that advises users to pick the appropriate one.

  • I cancould create a new tag, move the wiki contents to it, and retag the couple of existing questions.
  • We don't yet have any questions about Advanced Debugger, so we can't create a tag for that. Apple Desktop Bus hasn't been in use for awhile, so we may not get new questions for that particular use at this point.
  • Rather than synonomizing with a specific use, it should be turned into a "do not use" tag that guides readers to the appropriate choices. Right now, there's only one choice, so this would imply editing the wiki excerpt as other adb-related tags are created.
  • As Ben N points out in his answer, more users think in terms of "adb" than "Android Debug Bridge", so simply deleting the adb tag may complicate tagging for users.
  • I'm not aware of a way to link a tag to more than one other tag to preserve it, and I don't think synonomizing allows you to have a different wiki. It would also automatically link new question with the synonomized tag, which might be the wrong one.

What's the best general solution for acronym tags, especially when they are known, or likely, to refer to multiple things?

  • One thought: incorporate the acronym into the spelled-out tag. I don't know the limits on tag text (max characters, number of hyphenated terms, acceptable non-letter characters other than hyphen and I think period).

    If each spelled out tag includes "adb", something like: , they could potentially show up for selection when the user enters adb (as long as there aren't too manyadb. That isn't guaranteed, though. A maximum of 6 candidate tags that contain that letter combination; currently there are 6 in addition to displayed when the user starts typing a tag, and I believe the displayed subset is based on popularity). There are currently 6 in addition to that contain that letter combination.

  • Other ideas?

This question uses the tag as an example, but it applies to any acronym tag that doesn't have a universal and common usage (like, say, pdf).

is a new tag. I drafted a wiki and excerpt for it based on the usage so far (which refers to Android Debug Bridge). As DavidPostill points out in a comment, adb already has multiple computer-related uses (also Advanced Debugger), so an acronym tag is just asking for misuse.

Based on adb already referring to multiple things, the logical approach is to have spelled-out tags for each use and an adb tag that advises users to pick the appropriate one.

  • I can create a new tag, move the wiki contents to it, and retag the couple of existing questions.
  • We don't yet have any questions about Advanced Debugger, so we can't create a tag for that.
  • Rather than synonomizing with a specific use, it should be turned into a "do not use" tag that guides readers to the appropriate choices. Right now, there's only one choice, so this would imply editing the wiki excerpt as other adb-related tags are created.
  • As Ben N points out in his answer, more users think in terms of "adb" than "Android Debug Bridge", so simply deleting the adb tag may complicate tagging for users.
  • I'm not aware of a way to link a tag to more than one other tag to preserve it, and I don't think synonomizing allows you to have a different wiki. It would also automatically link new question with the synonomized tag, which might be the wrong one.

What's the best general solution for acronym tags, especially when they are known, or likely, to refer to multiple things?

  • One thought: incorporate the acronym into the spelled-out tag. I don't know the limits on tag text (max characters, number of hyphenated terms, acceptable non-letter characters other than hyphen and I think period).

    If each spelled out tag includes "adb", something like: , they could potentially show up for selection when the user enters adb (as long as there aren't too many tags that contain that letter combination; currently there are 6 in addition to , and I believe the displayed subset is based on popularity).

  • Other ideas?

This question uses the tag as an example, but it applies to any acronym tag that doesn't have a universal and common usage (like, say, pdf).

is a new tag. I drafted a wiki and excerpt for it based on the usage so far (which refers to Android Debug Bridge). ADB already has multiple computer-related uses (as DavidPostill points out in a comment, also Advanced Debugger, and user2943160 mentions Apple Desktop Bus), so an acronym tag is just asking for misuse.

Based on adb already referring to multiple things, the logical approach is to have spelled-out tags for each use and an adb tag that advises users to pick the appropriate one.

  • I could create a new tag, move the wiki contents to it, and retag the couple of existing questions.
  • We don't yet have any questions about Advanced Debugger, so we can't create a tag for that. Apple Desktop Bus hasn't been in use for awhile, so we may not get new questions for that particular use at this point.
  • Rather than synonomizing with a specific use, it should be turned into a "do not use" tag that guides readers to the appropriate choices. Right now, there's only one choice, so this would imply editing the wiki excerpt as other adb-related tags are created.
  • As Ben N points out in his answer, more users think in terms of "adb" than "Android Debug Bridge", so simply deleting the adb tag may complicate tagging for users.
  • I'm not aware of a way to link a tag to more than one other tag to preserve it, and I don't think synonomizing allows you to have a different wiki. It would also automatically link new question with the synonomized tag, which might be the wrong one.

What's the best general solution for acronym tags, especially when they are known, or likely, to refer to multiple things?

  • One thought: incorporate the acronym into the spelled-out tag. I don't know the limits on tag text (max characters, number of hyphenated terms, acceptable non-letter characters other than hyphen and I think period).

    If each spelled out tag includes "adb", something like: , they could potentially show up for selection when the user enters adb. That isn't guaranteed, though. A maximum of 6 candidate tags are displayed when the user starts typing a tag, and I believe the displayed subset is based on popularity. There are currently 6 in addition to that contain that letter combination.

  • Other ideas?

Tweeted twitter.com/super_user/status/769254565837406208
added 101 characters in body
Source Link
fixer1234
  • 27.8k
  • 2
  • 38
  • 96

This question uses the tag as an example, but it applies to any acronym tag that doesn't have a universal and common usage (like, say, pdf).

is a new tag. I drafted a wiki and excerpt for it based on the usage so far (which refers to Android Debug Bridge). As DavidPostill points out in a comment, adb already has multiple computer-related uses (also Advanced Debugger), so an acronym tag is just asking for misuse.

Based on adb already referring to multiple things, the logical approach is to have spelled-out tags for each use and an adb tag that advises users to pick the appropriate one.

  • I can create a new tag, move the wiki contents to it, and retag the couple of existing questions.
  • We don't yet have any questions about Advanced Debugger, so we can't create a tag for that.
  • Rather than synonomizing with a specific use, it should be turned into a "do not use" tag that guides readers to the appropriate choices. Right now, there's only one choice, so this would imply editing the wiki excerpt as other adb-related tags are created.
  • As Ben N points out in his answer, more users think in terms of "adb" than "Android Debug Bridge", so simply deleting the adb tag may complicate tagging for users.
  • I'm not aware of a way to link a tag to more than one other tag to preserve it, and I don't think synonomizing allows you to have a different wiki. It would also automatically link new question with the synonomized tag, which might be the wrong one.

What's the best general solution for acronym tags, especially when they are known, or likely, to refer to multiple things?

  • One thought: incorporate the acronym into the spelled-out tag. I don't know the limits on tag text (max characters, number of hyphenated terms, acceptable non-letter characters other than hyphen and I think period).

    If each spelled out tag includes "adb", something like: , they could potentially show up for selection when the user enters adb (as long as there aren't too many tags that contain that letter combination; currently there are 6 in addition to , and I believe the displayed subset is based on popularity).

  • Other ideas?

This question uses the tag as an example, but it applies to any acronym tag that doesn't have a universal and common usage (like, say, pdf).

is a new tag. I drafted a wiki and excerpt for it based on the usage so far (which refers to Android Debug Bridge). As DavidPostill points out in a comment, adb already has multiple computer-related uses (also Advanced Debugger), so an acronym tag is just asking for misuse.

Based on adb already referring to multiple things, the logical approach is to have spelled-out tags for each use and an adb tag that advises users to pick the appropriate one.

  • I can create a new tag, move the wiki contents to it, and retag the couple of existing questions.
  • We don't yet have any questions about Advanced Debugger, so we can't create a tag for that.
  • Rather than synonomizing with a specific use, it should be turned into a "do not use" tag that guides readers to the appropriate choices. Right now, there's only one choice, so this would imply editing the wiki excerpt as other adb-related tags are created.
  • As Ben N points out in his answer, more users think in terms of "adb" than "Android Debug Bridge", so simply deleting the adb tag may complicate tagging for users.
  • I'm not aware of a way to link a tag to more than one other tag to preserve it, and I don't think synonomizing allows you to have a different wiki.

What's the best general solution for acronym tags, especially when they are known, or likely, to refer to multiple things?

  • One thought: incorporate the acronym into the spelled-out tag. I don't know the limits on tag text (max characters, number of hyphenated terms, acceptable non-letter characters other than hyphen and I think period).

    If each spelled out tag includes "adb", something like: , they could potentially show up for selection when the user enters adb (as long as there aren't too many tags that contain that letter combination; currently there are 6 in addition to , and I believe the displayed subset is based on popularity).

  • Other ideas?

This question uses the tag as an example, but it applies to any acronym tag that doesn't have a universal and common usage (like, say, pdf).

is a new tag. I drafted a wiki and excerpt for it based on the usage so far (which refers to Android Debug Bridge). As DavidPostill points out in a comment, adb already has multiple computer-related uses (also Advanced Debugger), so an acronym tag is just asking for misuse.

Based on adb already referring to multiple things, the logical approach is to have spelled-out tags for each use and an adb tag that advises users to pick the appropriate one.

  • I can create a new tag, move the wiki contents to it, and retag the couple of existing questions.
  • We don't yet have any questions about Advanced Debugger, so we can't create a tag for that.
  • Rather than synonomizing with a specific use, it should be turned into a "do not use" tag that guides readers to the appropriate choices. Right now, there's only one choice, so this would imply editing the wiki excerpt as other adb-related tags are created.
  • As Ben N points out in his answer, more users think in terms of "adb" than "Android Debug Bridge", so simply deleting the adb tag may complicate tagging for users.
  • I'm not aware of a way to link a tag to more than one other tag to preserve it, and I don't think synonomizing allows you to have a different wiki. It would also automatically link new question with the synonomized tag, which might be the wrong one.

What's the best general solution for acronym tags, especially when they are known, or likely, to refer to multiple things?

  • One thought: incorporate the acronym into the spelled-out tag. I don't know the limits on tag text (max characters, number of hyphenated terms, acceptable non-letter characters other than hyphen and I think period).

    If each spelled out tag includes "adb", something like: , they could potentially show up for selection when the user enters adb (as long as there aren't too many tags that contain that letter combination; currently there are 6 in addition to , and I believe the displayed subset is based on popularity).

  • Other ideas?

added 564 characters in body; edited title
Source Link
fixer1234
  • 27.8k
  • 2
  • 38
  • 96

Replacement for [adb]; suggestions for handling How to handle acronym tags, especially if not unique?

Rewrite time: As DavidPostill points out in a comment, adb already has multiple computer-related This question uses, so the tag as an example, but it applies to any acronym tag is just asking for misusethat doesn't have a universal and common usage (like, say, pdf).

is a new tag. I drafted a wiki and excerpt for it based on the usage so far (which refers to Android Debug Bridge). It has only As DavidPostill points out in a couple of questionscomment, adb already has multiple computer-related uses (also Advanced Debugger), so any fix will be minimalan acronym tag is just asking for misuse.

Based on the new informationadb already referring to multiple things, the logical approach is to have spelled-out tags for each use and an adb tag that advises users to pick the appropriate one.

  • I can create a new tag, move the wiki contents to it, and retag the couple of existing questions.
  • We don't yet have any questions, yet, about Advanced Debugger, so we can't create a tag for that.
  • Rather than synonomizing with a specific use, it should be turned into a "do not use" tag that guides readers to the appropriate choices. Right now, there's only one choice, so this would imply editing the wiki excerpt as other adb-related tags are created. I'm
  • As Ben N points out in his answer, more users think in terms of "adb" than "Android Debug Bridge", so simply deleting the adb tag may complicate tagging for users.
  • I'm not aware of a way to link a tag to more than one other tag to preserve it, and I don't think synonomizing allows you to have a different wiki.

Ideas?What's the best general solution for acronym tags, especially when they are known, or likely, to refer to multiple things?

One thought. I don't know the limits on tag text (max characters, number of hyphenated terms, acceptability of non-letter characters other than hyphen; parentheses don't appear to be acceptable). One approach might be something like: . If each spelled out tag includes "adb", they will show up for selection when the user enters adb as long as there aren't too many tags that contain that letter combination somewhere (there are currently six in addition to , and I believe the displayed collection is based on popularity).

  • One thought: incorporate the acronym into the spelled-out tag. I don't know the limits on tag text (max characters, number of hyphenated terms, acceptable non-letter characters other than hyphen and I think period).

    If each spelled out tag includes "adb", something like: , they could potentially show up for selection when the user enters adb (as long as there aren't too many tags that contain that letter combination; currently there are 6 in addition to , and I believe the displayed subset is based on popularity).

  • Other ideas?

Replacement for [adb]; suggestions for handling?

Rewrite time: As DavidPostill points out in a comment, adb already has multiple computer-related uses, so an acronym tag is just asking for misuse.

is a new tag. I drafted a wiki and excerpt for it based on the usage so far. It has only a couple of questions, so any fix will be minimal.

Based on the new information, the logical approach is to have spelled-out tags for each use and an adb tag that advises users to pick the appropriate one.

  • I can create a new tag, move the wiki contents to it, and retag the existing questions.
  • We don't have any questions, yet, about Advanced Debugger, so we can't create a tag for that.
  • Rather than synonomizing with a specific use, it should be turned into a "do not use" tag that guides readers to the appropriate choices. Right now, there's only one choice. I'm not aware of a way to link a tag to more than one other tag to preserve it, and I don't think synonomizing allows you to have a different wiki.

Ideas?

One thought. I don't know the limits on tag text (max characters, number of hyphenated terms, acceptability of non-letter characters other than hyphen; parentheses don't appear to be acceptable). One approach might be something like: . If each spelled out tag includes "adb", they will show up for selection when the user enters adb as long as there aren't too many tags that contain that letter combination somewhere (there are currently six in addition to , and I believe the displayed collection is based on popularity).

How to handle acronym tags, especially if not unique?

This question uses the tag as an example, but it applies to any acronym tag that doesn't have a universal and common usage (like, say, pdf).

is a new tag. I drafted a wiki and excerpt for it based on the usage so far (which refers to Android Debug Bridge). As DavidPostill points out in a comment, adb already has multiple computer-related uses (also Advanced Debugger), so an acronym tag is just asking for misuse.

Based on adb already referring to multiple things, the logical approach is to have spelled-out tags for each use and an adb tag that advises users to pick the appropriate one.

  • I can create a new tag, move the wiki contents to it, and retag the couple of existing questions.
  • We don't yet have any questions about Advanced Debugger, so we can't create a tag for that.
  • Rather than synonomizing with a specific use, it should be turned into a "do not use" tag that guides readers to the appropriate choices. Right now, there's only one choice, so this would imply editing the wiki excerpt as other adb-related tags are created.
  • As Ben N points out in his answer, more users think in terms of "adb" than "Android Debug Bridge", so simply deleting the adb tag may complicate tagging for users.
  • I'm not aware of a way to link a tag to more than one other tag to preserve it, and I don't think synonomizing allows you to have a different wiki.

What's the best general solution for acronym tags, especially when they are known, or likely, to refer to multiple things?

  • One thought: incorporate the acronym into the spelled-out tag. I don't know the limits on tag text (max characters, number of hyphenated terms, acceptable non-letter characters other than hyphen and I think period).

    If each spelled out tag includes "adb", something like: , they could potentially show up for selection when the user enters adb (as long as there aren't too many tags that contain that letter combination; currently there are 6 in addition to , and I believe the displayed subset is based on popularity).

  • Other ideas?

added 571 characters in body
Source Link
fixer1234
  • 27.8k
  • 2
  • 38
  • 96
Loading
revision
Source Link
fixer1234
  • 27.8k
  • 2
  • 38
  • 96
Loading
Source Link
fixer1234
  • 27.8k
  • 2
  • 38
  • 96
Loading