Skip to main content
replaced http://superuser.com/ with https://superuser.com/
Source Link

Are hardware (port, cable, etc.) visual identification questions allowed or not? Specifically when it's basically just "What's this port?" and a picture.

Examples:

I've looked at Are "Guessing Game" type questions allowed on SU?, and @Random's answer is:

These should be closed as "too localised", or in the cases where they only have just an image and want you to figure out what they're showing, "not a real question".

Neither of these are options to close anymore. :)

I also have seen Let’s Play The Guessing Game, but it doesn't really help clarify it for me, especially this many years later.

Should we flag as Close -> Other and put in a reason (as I did on the latest one, and a previous one) such as in the following?

This question appears to be off-topic because it is a "guessing-game" type question. See https://meta.superuser.com/a/6074/23133

Or are we allowing these now (one of the examples above was even protected by @nhinkle)?

In the past I've answered one or two of them myself, but since these questions aren't really searchable, are they useful enough to keep?

This is the only closed question of the same type/style I can (currently) find with some quick searching:

Are hardware (port, cable, etc.) visual identification questions allowed or not? Specifically when it's basically just "What's this port?" and a picture.

Examples:

I've looked at Are "Guessing Game" type questions allowed on SU?, and @Random's answer is:

These should be closed as "too localised", or in the cases where they only have just an image and want you to figure out what they're showing, "not a real question".

Neither of these are options to close anymore. :)

I also have seen Let’s Play The Guessing Game, but it doesn't really help clarify it for me, especially this many years later.

Should we flag as Close -> Other and put in a reason (as I did on the latest one, and a previous one) such as in the following?

This question appears to be off-topic because it is a "guessing-game" type question. See https://meta.superuser.com/a/6074/23133

Or are we allowing these now (one of the examples above was even protected by @nhinkle)?

In the past I've answered one or two of them myself, but since these questions aren't really searchable, are they useful enough to keep?

This is the only closed question of the same type/style I can (currently) find with some quick searching:

Are hardware (port, cable, etc.) visual identification questions allowed or not? Specifically when it's basically just "What's this port?" and a picture.

Examples:

I've looked at Are "Guessing Game" type questions allowed on SU?, and @Random's answer is:

These should be closed as "too localised", or in the cases where they only have just an image and want you to figure out what they're showing, "not a real question".

Neither of these are options to close anymore. :)

I also have seen Let’s Play The Guessing Game, but it doesn't really help clarify it for me, especially this many years later.

Should we flag as Close -> Other and put in a reason (as I did on the latest one, and a previous one) such as in the following?

This question appears to be off-topic because it is a "guessing-game" type question. See https://meta.superuser.com/a/6074/23133

Or are we allowing these now (one of the examples above was even protected by @nhinkle)?

In the past I've answered one or two of them myself, but since these questions aren't really searchable, are they useful enough to keep?

This is the only closed question of the same type/style I can (currently) find with some quick searching:

replaced http://meta.superuser.com/ with https://meta.superuser.com/
Source Link
replaced http://meta.superuser.com/ with https://meta.superuser.com/
Source Link

Are hardware (port, cable, etc.) visual identification questions allowed or not? Specifically when it's basically just "What's this port?" and a picture.

Examples:

I've looked at Are "Guessing Game" type questions allowed on SU?Are "Guessing Game" type questions allowed on SU?, and @Random's answer is:

These should be closed as "too localised", or in the cases where they only have just an image and want you to figure out what they're showing, "not a real question".

Neither of these are options to close anymore. :)

I also have seen Let’s Play The Guessing Game, but it doesn't really help clarify it for me, especially this many years later.

Should we flag as Close -> Other and put in a reason (as I did on the latest one, and a previous one) such as in the following?

This question appears to be off-topic because it is a "guessing-game" type question. See http://meta.superuser.com/a/6074/23133https://meta.superuser.com/a/6074/23133

Or are we allowing these now (one of the examples above was even protected by @nhinkle)?

In the past I've answered one or two of them myself, but since these questions aren't really searchable, are they useful enough to keep?

This is the only closed question of the same type/style I can (currently) find with some quick searching:

Are hardware (port, cable, etc.) visual identification questions allowed or not? Specifically when it's basically just "What's this port?" and a picture.

Examples:

I've looked at Are "Guessing Game" type questions allowed on SU?, and @Random's answer is:

These should be closed as "too localised", or in the cases where they only have just an image and want you to figure out what they're showing, "not a real question".

Neither of these are options to close anymore. :)

I also have seen Let’s Play The Guessing Game, but it doesn't really help clarify it for me, especially this many years later.

Should we flag as Close -> Other and put in a reason (as I did on the latest one, and a previous one) such as in the following?

This question appears to be off-topic because it is a "guessing-game" type question. See http://meta.superuser.com/a/6074/23133

Or are we allowing these now (one of the examples above was even protected by @nhinkle)?

In the past I've answered one or two of them myself, but since these questions aren't really searchable, are they useful enough to keep?

This is the only closed question of the same type/style I can (currently) find with some quick searching:

Are hardware (port, cable, etc.) visual identification questions allowed or not? Specifically when it's basically just "What's this port?" and a picture.

Examples:

I've looked at Are "Guessing Game" type questions allowed on SU?, and @Random's answer is:

These should be closed as "too localised", or in the cases where they only have just an image and want you to figure out what they're showing, "not a real question".

Neither of these are options to close anymore. :)

I also have seen Let’s Play The Guessing Game, but it doesn't really help clarify it for me, especially this many years later.

Should we flag as Close -> Other and put in a reason (as I did on the latest one, and a previous one) such as in the following?

This question appears to be off-topic because it is a "guessing-game" type question. See https://meta.superuser.com/a/6074/23133

Or are we allowing these now (one of the examples above was even protected by @nhinkle)?

In the past I've answered one or two of them myself, but since these questions aren't really searchable, are they useful enough to keep?

This is the only closed question of the same type/style I can (currently) find with some quick searching:

Made the body self-contained. Copy edited. Dressed a naked link. Changed to sentence casing for the title.
Source Link
Peter Mortensen
  • 12.3k
  • 16
  • 11
Loading
Tweeted twitter.com/#!/super_user/status/429564091234287616
Negated an example. It didnt fit so much.
Source Link
Ƭᴇcʜιᴇ007
  • 113.5k
  • 15
  • 18
Loading
Source Link
Ƭᴇcʜιᴇ007
  • 113.5k
  • 15
  • 18
Loading