Skip to main content
replaced http://superuser.com/ with https://superuser.com/
Source Link

I flagged a post for deletion that was (IMO) low qualitylow quality being that it was more of a comment/question for more information than an answer. I had also posted onto the same question a duplicate answerduplicate answer that was (again IMO) higher quality as it actually answer the question instead of posing a question. However I posted after the initial answer (I can't remember what my reasoning behind it was).

In the flag I describe the situation as the flagged post was a more of a comment than an answer, and that the answer was clearer in my answer. The flag was declined with the following reason:

declined - this was posted before you even answered

While I don't really care about the declined flag, nor am I trying to get rid of a "competing" answer, I am more curious what to do about this type of situation where:

  1. There are two answer identical in solution but different in quality
  2. The newer question is of a higher quality than the original

What should we do in this type of situation?

I flagged a post for deletion that was (IMO) low quality being that it was more of a comment/question for more information than an answer. I had also posted onto the same question a duplicate answer that was (again IMO) higher quality as it actually answer the question instead of posing a question. However I posted after the initial answer (I can't remember what my reasoning behind it was).

In the flag I describe the situation as the flagged post was a more of a comment than an answer, and that the answer was clearer in my answer. The flag was declined with the following reason:

declined - this was posted before you even answered

While I don't really care about the declined flag, nor am I trying to get rid of a "competing" answer, I am more curious what to do about this type of situation where:

  1. There are two answer identical in solution but different in quality
  2. The newer question is of a higher quality than the original

What should we do in this type of situation?

I flagged a post for deletion that was (IMO) low quality being that it was more of a comment/question for more information than an answer. I had also posted onto the same question a duplicate answer that was (again IMO) higher quality as it actually answer the question instead of posing a question. However I posted after the initial answer (I can't remember what my reasoning behind it was).

In the flag I describe the situation as the flagged post was a more of a comment than an answer, and that the answer was clearer in my answer. The flag was declined with the following reason:

declined - this was posted before you even answered

While I don't really care about the declined flag, nor am I trying to get rid of a "competing" answer, I am more curious what to do about this type of situation where:

  1. There are two answer identical in solution but different in quality
  2. The newer question is of a higher quality than the original

What should we do in this type of situation?

edited tags
Link
random Mod
  • 15.2k
  • 42
  • 63
Source Link
James Mertz
  • 26.5k
  • 3
  • 37
  • 76

How do we handle duplicate answers?

I flagged a post for deletion that was (IMO) low quality being that it was more of a comment/question for more information than an answer. I had also posted onto the same question a duplicate answer that was (again IMO) higher quality as it actually answer the question instead of posing a question. However I posted after the initial answer (I can't remember what my reasoning behind it was).

In the flag I describe the situation as the flagged post was a more of a comment than an answer, and that the answer was clearer in my answer. The flag was declined with the following reason:

declined - this was posted before you even answered

While I don't really care about the declined flag, nor am I trying to get rid of a "competing" answer, I am more curious what to do about this type of situation where:

  1. There are two answer identical in solution but different in quality
  2. The newer question is of a higher quality than the original

What should we do in this type of situation?