Skip to main content
AFH's user avatar
AFH's user avatar
AFH's user avatar
AFH
  • Member for 10 years, 6 months
  • Last seen more than 5 years ago
  • Lancashire, UK
awarded
awarded
awarded
awarded
awarded
awarded
awarded
awarded
awarded
comment
Reputation doesn't increase
You should have added new log-in credentials to your previous account in order to retain your reputation. You do not gain reputation for asking a question unless it is marked up (which none of your questions on this account have been).
awarded
awarded
comment
Show comment count on search list
@Robotnik - Indeed I wasn't talking about the front page: this has only votes and answers, so certainly doesn't need complicating. I meant the search page, which currently shows the view count, and I contend that this is less useful to someone looking for an answer than the comment count.
comment
Show comment count on search list
Thanks for the feedback. I agree about the dangers of clutter, but in some ways the number of views could already be regarded as clutter, and personally I would find the comment count more useful. What, after all, is the value of knowing the number of views? Either the title is of interest to a reader, especially if there is an answer, or it isn't. The number of other people who find it interesting is largely irrelevant.
comment
Show comment count on search list
I agree that too many comments are unlikely to be useful, which is why the count would be such a benefit on the search results. Often comments are "Have you tried...?", which is not an answer, but may be very relevant to others viewing the question. I agree that the comment count should be in a different colour from the answer and view counts, though I don't see much advantage in colour-coding the size of the number.
revised
Loading…
awarded
awarded
comment
Penalty for unexplained down-votes
@random - Fine. Will do.
comment
Penalty for unexplained down-votes
@Random - I did look quite hard for previous instances this question before I posted it, but none of my searches found your link. I agree that it is the same question. Since it has already been considered and answered, I am content to withdraw it.