5

I can see some questions like 'where can i get the cheapest X' and other members might have X and want to sell.

I have mixed feelings as to whether or not that should be allowed, but it would be interesting to see some opinions on it.

migrated from meta.stackexchange.com Jul 22 '10 at 17:55

This question came from our discussion, support, and feature requests site for meta-discussion of the Stack Exchange family of Q&A websites.

25

I don't like the idea of SuperUser being your personal Amazon or eBay. The questions asking "where I can get the cheapest X" are already annoying as it is.

Edit: I should probably revise this some now that I am actually a moderator of the website.

So far there have been lots and lots of questions looking for product recommendations when it comes to specific issues ("I need a free/cheap video editing software"). These questions I have no real problem with (as long as they are not duplicates of something already posted). This will allow for people to post their recommendations and there can actually be a correct answer (what the OP decides to end up going with).

I find these type of questions are much better than "Where can I find the cheapest router" or "I need to find a place where I can buy [X] for less than $50". There are plenty of websites out there already which allow you to do specific product searches and compare prices among other websites, we don't need SuperUser to devolve into that. I do think that SuperUser's community can be a helpful source of product recommendations, however.

  • I'd upvote this +10 if I could. Well said. – Dillie-O Jul 15 '09 at 16:01
  • 1
    Another question is : How does the question "I need a free/cheap video editing software" ages ? – Steve Schnepp Jul 29 '09 at 5:39
  • 1
    yeah, we need to start enforcing those last 2 paragraphs or codifying them into the FAQ. – Jeff Atwood Aug 13 '09 at 8:27
5

Ugh, let's not become Craigslist without the "adult services" section. I can't imagine anything worse.

  • 27
    I agree. We definitely need adult services. – Kyle Cronin Jul 15 '09 at 16:12
  • 1
    @Kyle I just chuckled imagining how such questions and especially answers would shape up. – Camilo Martin Feb 12 '12 at 13:28
5

There was a question where someone was asking if he could still get data off of some old 5 1/4 disks. All I did was append to my answer that I had some spare parts, and it got down-voted immediately. I have since removed that from my answer.

I wasn't really trying to sell him, or anybody, anything. I was just trying to be helpful.

  • Did you mention "I could sell these spare parts I have if you wanted" or something? I'd downvote such beahavior, but since you look like you're in the clear, +1. – Camilo Martin Feb 12 '12 at 13:31
4

All I saw today was somebody asking where they can buy hardware for cheap...I suggested newegg, and that was it :)

2

If someone's asked for the cheapest X then I can't see there being a serious problem if a vendor of X comes along and says get it here. There could be issues around the wording etc, but it would have to be on a case-by-case basis.

The problem might be that the question's been posted in the first place.

Where there would be a problem is if the vendor posted the advert (for want of a better word) as a question.

1

Don't forget you can flag as Spam. The worse case is "How do I solve X?" with an answer "Use product Y" (where Y is a referral link, and doesn't actually solve the problem).

It would be neat if the system could automagically either de-referrer them (or potentially better for the site as a whole) automagically substitute for a StackOverflow referral tag. For things like books,

I also like Wikipedia's approach if sending you to a landing page, with referral links for all the major online bookstores (based on ISBN)

You must log in to answer this question.