Stack Exchange network consists of 183 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers.
@robinCTS if i dont use the "@user", will users who left a comment in the past will be notified about my new comment? Or do I have to use your suggested "work around"?
I gave the whole issue some thought, and I have a few point I would like do discuss in regards to my edit. Even on a subjective basis, I have some doubts that the reasons you guys presented for rejecting my review don't contradict themselves. I'm not sure if the comments are a good place for such a discussion. Would it be better to open a chat room?
@robinCTS (I hope the others will read my comment as well it seems I can only adress one person at a time) thanks everyone those comments give me a better insight. I see a pattern of a general consents emerging between users with high reputation levels emerging here. I think one of the problems is, that the goals/rules of reviewing are not defined very well in the help center. The term "make it significantly better" is very subjective which makes it a very bad guideline for newcomers.
on a side note: not allowing for a small quality improvement on a proposal doesn't sound logical in the big picture. The ultimate goal is to improve quality of the questions and answers. Beside the organizational issue (that it gets bumped to the top of the list, which is a fault by design an can be changed) I don't see a reason to limit proposals to large improvements. But I could name several good reasons to allow small improvements. - should I post this as a new question?
@Run5k thanks now I understand the why. Not really sure why Ramhound kept repeating that I didn't correct all the misstakes since I wrote in my first comment that I understood this point, or did I miss s.th.? Thanks Ramhound for pointing out the help center, that helped!
