5

When suggested edits were introduced, I had more rep than required to edit on my own.

Since I'm now approving and rejecting suggested edits, I'd like to know how approval and rejection are presented to the users that suggest them.

I can see how the suggested edits form looks like when logging out. But I don't want to suggest edits just to see the results, and I'm not sure if anonymous user/Community suggested edits responses appear identical to regular, lower-rep users'.

Are they in the global inbox? In the users profile, and if so, where? Responses? Activity?

Some screenshots with a general description would be nice.

4

They aren't actively "pushed" to your inbox. The only way to find out if an edit suggestion was accepted or rejected is to:

  • Check your reputation
  • Check your activity

This applies to both approved and rejected edits. You will not be notified. At least I didn't get a notification for this.


Looking at your reputation

For example, if your reputation changed by +2, obviously, your edit was accepted:

enter image description here

But that doesn't show you anything about rejected edits.

Looking under Activity

You can also go to your Profile » Activity » Suggestions. Here you'll find all your suggested edits. Still, this page doesn't list whether an edit was approved or rejected.

enter image description here

Looking at the individual edits

You have to click the "suggested edit" link to actually find out:

enter image description here

Further scrolling down, you can see more about your recent editor statistics:

enter image description here

  • Can't talk about whether there's any other procedure for rejected edits, as I've never had one. I would doubt there is a difference though. Needless to say I think that this procedure could be way more verbose for the user suggesting edits. – slhck Jan 29 '12 at 13:02
  • The rejected edits would be most interesting, as I wonder exactly how pointless giving good reasons for rejection is. That approval as the "default" doesn't generate any notification is understandable. – Daniel Beck Jan 29 '12 at 13:08
  • Do you think that would make a nice feature request? – Daniel Beck Jan 29 '12 at 13:34
  • 1
    Absolutely. At least rejection messages should be made a notification bar like the "You have 1 new response … " message. Otherwise what's the point? You'll never be able to teach users otherwise. I might consider looking on MSO if there's something similar already and post it there later on, unless you want to post it here? – slhck Jan 29 '12 at 13:37
  • Exactly what I feared. Please go ahead on MSO. – Daniel Beck Jan 29 '12 at 13:45

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .