1

I have a doubt of what exactly is the scope of SU and Unix/Linux Websites, when it comes to Questions about Unix.

I have seen a few questions, one example is

While the question is within the scope of SuperUser, it would receive a better response on the Unix/Linux Website. Yet, flagging it as out-of-place would be wrong.

Do you think we should better define the scope of the two sites? Especially so that all Unix/Linux related questions can be assembled on one single website, making it easier for people to search for answers too.

Superuser vs Unix/Linux vs Ubuntu on Meta handles the same issue, but I could not get any good definite answers out of it.

As does Migrating questions to the Ubuntu or Linux/Unix Stack Exchange sites which clearly asks about the scopes of the two websites.

Currently, if I have an issue, I could find the answer on either Unix/Linux or SU.

  • 2
    considering at least 4 of our top 8 users (in terms of rep) have almost exclusively answered on *nix, I disgree with your statement that the question might receive better response on Unix & Linux – Sathyajith Bhat Nov 2 '12 at 5:55
  • Most people are arriving here from search engines like Google anyway, deemphasizing the site for those just looking for a quick answer to their problem. – Daniel Beck Nov 2 '12 at 7:23
  • I agree with this statement (and don't see why this question was downvoted). I'm also not convinced that the fact that 4 of top 8 users earned most of their rep in *nix questions justifies *nix related questions. It seems to me as a side effect, not the reason. – Eugene S Aug 26 '13 at 8:58
  • Something I've noticed is that *nix questions on SU tend to be fairly simple in comparison to the questions asked on U&L. – Drew Chapin Sep 10 '13 at 0:03
4

While the question is within the scope of SuperUser, it would receive a better response on the Unix/Linux Website

I wouldn't say so. While Super User's topics are probably more diverse due to Windows and OS X questions, we have tens of thousands questions for Linux, Ubuntu, Bash et cetera. People wouldn't ask here if this site wasn't a good fit for these questions.

Especially so that all Unix/Linux related questions can be assembled on one single website, making it easier for people to search for answers too

They could be, but you forget that these are all communities. If one spends a little time on these sites, they'll see that the communities are different from each other in so many other ways. It also depends on what kinds of questions are considered on-topic or not. For example, U&L might welcome historical questions that aren't based on an actual problem more than we do. On the other hand, if you know the users here,

I'll quote DMA57361♦ from the question you linked to:

The sites have different community spirits and different community goals, so it's important that if a user attempts to interact with one of these communities that we don't push them away. So if someone has made the effort to ask a valid question on SU, we will not automatically shunt it to another site.

So, regarding that, we're very well aware of the scope overlap—and this is something that sometimes confuses me as well from time to time—but then again, you're free to ask wherever you feel like.

Currently, if I have an issue, I could find the answer on either Unix/Linux or SU.

Yes. One might argue though that when you're using web search you'll land on either site anyway, so it doesn't really matter. Stack Exchange search could definitely be improved a little to either work across sites or pull in more relevant results from other sites as well, but if you're really looking to solve an issue you would probably extend your search to the whole web anyway.

All in all, I don't think we need to redefine scope other than what the FAQs of both sites say. Ask wherever you feel like, as long as your question is on-topic.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .