0

Why was chosen as the authoritative tag and made the synonym instead of the other way around?

Directories are always directories in filesystems. A folder is an almost-cardboard thing with a crease in it, used for holding papers and other stuff.

I understand trying to make things easier for users to understand, and Microsoft has done a devil of a time playing with the language, just to be different, but the use of the term "folder" just seems silly.

So, I was wondering what, if any rationale there was for the decision to make the authoritative tag.

  • Related. – Bob Jun 11 '13 at 12:16
  • @Bob So, if (in Windows language), a folder is essentially a mutant form of a directory, possibly/probably just a kernel construct (again, because Microsoft wants to be different), shouldn't "directory" be the authoritative and "folder" be the "odd man out"? How often does someone talk, exclusively about one of these things that is a virtual construct by Microsoft, where some other tag wouldn't be more appropriate? – killermist Jun 11 '13 at 12:24
  • Not really sure why directory was merged into folder but @Sathya merged them. Maybe he remembers. – Der Hochstapler Jun 11 '13 at 13:12
  • @OliverSalzburg I don't mind that they were merged. It makes sense. But EVERY time I see a user talking about a "folder", they're really talking about a directory, and a red flag goes off in my head saying "Why is this person playing with a piece of creased cardboard?" So, I have to wonder how the entirely wrong term came out as the "leader". (yes, I am often a very literal person) – killermist Jun 11 '13 at 13:17
  • Since in Windows all directories are folders, I don't see what the problem is with having directory as the synonym of folder. The term folder encompasses everything. – Karan Jun 12 '13 at 14:55
  • @Karan I strongly disagree. In anything unix-like, there is no such thing as a "folder" except when misguided developers intentionally choose the wrong word to be noob (which is to say windows user)-friendly. It is one thing that so frustrates me about many programs, like file managers in Linux, where something is called a folder, and I want to yell at the program, "It's a friggin' directory! Quit using that broken Windows language!" And I think that preferring folder to directory here continues to perpetuate broken language. – killermist Jun 12 '13 at 16:13
  • Meh, I'm not concerned either way. I still use directory most of the time, as I guess would anyone who used DOS before Windows. Personally I don't think this is anything great to lose sleep over or even something that requires changing, but perhaps the community feels as passionately about this as you do... – Karan Jun 12 '13 at 17:54
  • I think this is interesting but unanswerable. I would agree that Directory is the 'better' but the 2 terms does cause ambiguity & since a folder is an abstract references of the same thing, I'd personally merge them. A search for "unix folders" in Google returns results where Unix people are using this term interchangeably as well so I don't think this was due to Windows! Of course any OS / software which displays a directory with a folder icon will cause this ambiguity. – Dave Jun 13 '13 at 7:57
  • @DaveRook I think it is one of those clear cases of MS mutating the language, and because their userbase is so big, and has some bleedover into unix-like users, some people (just by not paying attention) accidentally started using the wrong word. Having once been a MS user and grown up and figured out the error of my ways, having been guilty of having used the wrong word for so long, I now see clearly how wrong that word is outside of Windows. Which is why I now have red flags go off in my head when I see the wrong word used. – killermist Jun 13 '13 at 11:47
  • Makes me want to find the code for linux programs that use the wrong word and commit patches to them that change the wrong word to the right word. Take back the language. The language shouldn't be Microsoft's to control. – killermist Jun 13 '13 at 11:49
  • @killermist - Try re-reading your comments, it comes across as very biased. Sorry, I'm not going to discuss this with you, you don't have an opinion, you have a view and therefore any rational is some what pointless. – Dave Jun 14 '13 at 18:04

You must log in to answer this question.

Browse other questions tagged .